I hadn’t had Yorkshire Pudding in ages, and was really craving it. I have no idea why – I’ve been watching Hawaii Five-O, and all my other recent food cravings have been Hawaiian. But I wanted it. So I had to figure out what on Earth even went in it.
Basic Yorkshire Pudding Ingredients:
- one part flour
- one part milk
- lots of eggs
- generously oiled pan
Additional things that went into mine:
- pizza seasoning
- shredded cheddar
Start your oven preheating to 425°F, put a generous coating of oil in the bottom of the pan, and stick your pan in while the oven is preheating. You want the oil pretty hot, and assembling everything else goes really fast.
Throw together your basics. I used a cup of flour, a cup of milk, and a little over half a small container of egg substitute. I don’t think just egg whites would work. Traditional recipes vary wildly – partly because it’s such a staple in Yorkshire that it’s basically ‘throw together what’s on hand and stick it in the fire.’ Seriously. The recipes I looked at had a 150°F spread in recommended temperature. Whisk or beat that together until it’s all smooth. Take your pan out and pout all of the batter in.
I then threw on a bunch of pepperoni and a generous shake of pizza seasoning. It seemed like an easier idea at the time than making gravy? It tasted really good, anyway, even though I used too much oil in the pan. Lack of depth perception is bad for when you’re trying to gauge the difference between ‘a generous layer’ and ‘almost a quarter of an inch, what the fuck.’
Pop that in the oven for 15-20 minutes or until it turns golden brown on top. Check on it with your oven light: you don’t want to open the door until it’s done or it’ll collapse like a soufflé. Mine looked kind of disappointing and sad at 18 minutes, so I opened the door, threw on a double handful of shredded cheddar, and then closed the door and put the oven on the high broil setting. Melted cheese makes everything better. This is fact and not a result of bias stemming from living in Wisconsin, home of the cheeseheads. When the cheese was melty and it looked more delicious, I took it out of the oven and cut it into quarters. It tasted amazing.